The day I almost lost Eve in the bay

By Brian & Eve · June 15, 2026

The day I almost lost Eve in the bay

I had gotten cocky. Eve's recall at home was great. In the backyard it was great. So one morning at Crissy Field, with the water a comfortable distance away, I unclipped her.

For about ninety seconds it was the picture I'd imagined when I adopted her: a happy dog trotting along the shoreline, sniffing, glancing back at me. Then a small duck paddled out on the water.

I have never seen her move like that. She was gone before I finished saying her name, straight into the bay, swimming hard after a bird she was never going to catch. I called her. I called her louder. I was basically screaming her name at a dog who, I now understand, could not hear a word of it. When a dog is locked onto prey, the part of the brain that listens to you is not driving anymore.

She gave up on the duck on her own, turned around, and swam back, soaked and thrilled with herself. I was shaking. It could have gone a very different way with a current or a boat.

Here is what that morning taught me, and what I'd tell anyone with a chase-y dog:

  • Recall that works at home is not recall that works near a duck. Different planet.
  • A dog in full prey drive is not ignoring you. They genuinely cannot process the cue. Yelling louder does nothing except teach you that yelling does nothing.
  • Until recall is truly proofed around real temptation, the open-water, off-leash version of your dog should not exist. Manage the environment instead of trusting it.

I don't beat myself up about adopting a dog with a big prey drive. That's just who Eve is. But I stopped pretending I could shortcut the training, and I went back to building recall the slow, boring, reliable way.

Read the related post

More stories about Eve